Chapter
1: A history of Reintroduction and other Conservation Translocations
Philip J. Seddon
Department of Zoology,
University of Otago, POBox 56, Dunedin 9016, New Zealand
Abstract
If Conservation
Biology is a discipline born out of the crisis of biodiversity declines, then Reintroduction Biology is a discipline
born out of the management response to that crisis. Reintroduction, the re-establishment of a viable population of a
species within are area of its indigenous range from which it has disappeared,
is one of a number of types of Conservation
Translocation, defined as the intentional movement and release of a living
organisms for conservation benefit. Many early conservation translocations were
marked by poor planning, lack of adequate monitoring, and low success rates. In
1988 the IUCN created the Reintroduction Specialist Group (RSG) to promote the
use of translocation as a conservation tool, and in 1998 the RSG produced the
first simple guidelines to reintroduction planning. In 2013 the RSG published a
larger, fully revised version of the guidelines, encompassing not only the increasingly
common approaches of population reinforcement and reintroduction, but also
considering the more risky and controversial Conservation Introductions, Assisted
Colonization and Ecological
Replacements. The development of the discipline of Reintroduction Biology
paralleled that of the RSG as reintroduction practitioners sought to involve
researchers in conservation translocation planning and assessment. Partly as a
result of the efforts of the RSG, and due to some high profile reintroduction
success stories, there has been exponential growth in both projects and
research outputs. The foundations for Reintroduction Biology, the study of the
establishment, growth, regulation, and ecological role of translocated
populations, were laid only in the last 10 years.
This chapter will
review the history of the use of animal translocations as a conservation tool
and the development of the discipline of Reintroduction Biology, from the first
(unsuccessful) attempts back in the 1800s, to the comprehensively planned and
rigorously executed projects that are starting to characterise the field today.
With reference to case studies, three phases in the development of
translocations as a management approach will be described: an era of heroic
actions to avert extinctions; increasing post-release monitoring and the
documentation of outcome enabling retrospective analysis; increased strategic
directions and the use of experimental approaches and modelling tools.
I present the IUCN’s
Translocation Spectrum and review the risks and benefits of the range of
translocation options. I consider the controversy around risky actions, such as
Assisted Colonization, but argue that in the face of climate change and other
threats we need to move away from restoration targets that are set at some
arbitrary point in time and instead make informed decisions about how we want
the world around us to look. I touch on some new developments, including the
prospect of species DeExtinction.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 2: A
Paleoecological Perspective on Reintroduction: Benchmarks, Time Depths,
Concepts
R. Lee Lyman, University of Missouri
Conservation biologists working on
reintroduction need the most complete information possible on multiple
variables to insure success of their efforts.
The prefix “re” in reintroduction indicates the organism to be
transplanted was present at some time in the past in the area to which
individuals are to translocated.
Historical ranges may be construed as either places for which written records
are available, or places where a taxon was found at any time in the past
irrespective of written records. Ranges
are dynamic, so establishing an organism’s original range requires temporal
boundaries. An organism’s natural range
is one that was not determined by anthropogenic influences; paleoecological
data indicate some prehistoric introductions and range constrictions were
anthropogenic. Paleoecological research
may reveal stressful habitats and natural habitats, and appropriate genotypes
and phenotypes for reintroductions.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 3: Human Dimensions of Fish and Wildlife Reintroductions
Shawn J. Riley, Department of Fisheries and
Wildlife, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824, USA;
Camilla Sandström, Department of Political Science, Umeå
University, Umeå, Sweden 901 87;
Biological and
ecological considerations of fish and wildlife reintroductions to their native
range are complex, dynamic, and uncertain.
Yet, reintroductions are product of contemporary democratic
decision-making under governance of natural systems. Human dimensions of reintroductions – aspects
of the decision space not directly about the organism and its habitat – parallel
the complexities and uncertainties associated with the biology. This combination of biological and ecological
considerations and human dimension aspects makes reintroductions and
restoration distinct from traditional conservation and preservation governance
which often are based on the assumption that humans are or should not be
part of nature, to a more inclusive and active role of actors to engage in the
assistance of the reintroduction. Achieving social acceptance is thus
key to successful reintroduction efforts regardless of the capability of the
reintroduced species to thrive.
This chapter provides an
overview of individual and cultural factors affecting acceptability of fish and
wildlife reintroductions – natural recolonization and active reintroduction –
as well as provides a model to guide the thoughts and action of conservation
managers in planning and executing more successful reintroductions. Because nearly all reintroductions are
actions by or with government, key principles of good governance are
discussed. For example, increased demand
for greater participation by a growing set of stakeholders in decisions about
conservation necessitates attention to issues of transparency, inclusion, fairness,
and efficiency. Efficiency and cost
effectiveness of reintroductions can be enhanced if conservationists recognize
the form and function of differing models of governance under which
reintroductions are occurring; differences between representative, corporatism, participatory, and other
forms are discussed relative to reintroductions with attention to scale. We draw on impact management as a means of
encouraging resource professionals to view reintroductions more as a process
within a system, rather than a specific event or particular technique. Case
studies to emphasize principles from the chapter include: political discourse
from reintroductions of wildlife in Scotland; insights into public
participation and perceptions of fairness in moose reintroductions in the
Adirondacks Mountains of New York; related governance issues in reintroduction
of large predators to Fennoscandia; social considerations of fish
reintroductions in the Great Lakes; human dimension insights and processes in
planning for reintroduction of Florida Panthers; and, governance of Rewilding
Europe.
Cases:
- Koen Arts and Anke Fischer (University of Aberdeen, Scotland) – political discourse related to reintroductions
- Bruce Lauber (Cornell University, Ithaca, New York) – citizen participation and fairness in decision-making about moose reintroduction in the Adirondack Mountains.
- Charles Krueger (Michigan State University) and Tammy Neucomb (Michigan Department of Natural Resources) – social considerations in reintroduction of fish in the Great Lakes.
- Ann Forstchen (Florida Wildlife Conservation Commission) – human dimensions insights in preparation for reintroduction of Florida Panthers.
- Carl Gustav Thulin (Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences) – social consideration in rewilding Europe
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter
4: The Reintroduction Landscape: Finding Success at the Intersection of Ecological, Social, and Institutional Dimensions
Jason B. Dunham1, Bruce G. Marcot2,
Dan Shively3, Chris S. Allen4, Rollie White4
1U.S. Geological
Survey, Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center, 3200 SW Jefferson Way,
Corvallis, Oregon 97331; jdunham@usgs.gov
2U.S. Forest
Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station, 620 Southwest Main Street,
Portland, Oregon 97205, USA
3U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, Regional Office, 911 Northeast 11 th Avenue, Portland, Oregon
97232, USA
4U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service, Oregon Fish and Wildlife Office, 2600 Southeast 98th Avenue,
Portland, Oregon 97266, USA
Abstract
- The process
of selecting a location for reintroductions is hierarchical, involving
determination of the historical and current ecological ranges of a species
and within them evaluating local physical and biological suitability of
sites. Sites alone are often not
sufficient for meeting a species’ ecological needs because they are not independent
of the surrounding landscape.
Landscape configuration, composition, and spatial and temporal
variability in the patterns of disturbance, can be key determinants of
site suitability. To illustrate our
points, we offer examples from diverse taxa and ecosystems. We then review the literature for
habitat characteristics considered that resulted in both successful and
failed reintroductions, from which we hypothesize the relative importance
of physical and biotic conditions for successful site selection and the
influence of landscape-scale patterns and other considerations (e.g.,
climate and land use change).
- Following
our evaluation of site characteristics, we turn to discuss the role of
socio-economic considerations for site selection, including public
outreach and communication, and the role of stakeholders in a shared
structured decision-making framework.
These considerations are driven by the regulatory environment, and
we provide examples of how the U.S. Endangered Species Act has been applied
for reintroductions, including how the Act prescribes prohibitions to
protect threatened and endangered species, and provisions to allow
flexibility for reintroductions.
Lessons learned from implementing such provisions are applicable to
other regulatory environments.
- We
summarize key points and lessons with reference to physical, biotic,
social, and institutional considerations in site selection. With this, we conclude by addressing
emerging topics that will play an increasing role in site selection, including
habitat restoration, management of nonnative species, and long-range
planning or adaptation for addressing the uncertain effects of climate and
land use change. Concern over these
issues is reflected by the increasing attention paid to translocation
(introduction of a species outside of its range), assisted migration (a
variation on the theme of translocation), and anticipation of novel
ecosystems or “no-analog” communities.
Although these issues and concepts are not well developed in
practice, they are an important part of the evolving dialogue regarding
site selection and species reintroductions.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 5: Setting objectives and defining the success
of reintroductions
Alienor L. M.
Chauvenet; National Wildlife Management Centre, AHVLA, UK & Institute of
Zoology, ZSL, UK; alienor.chauvenet@ioz.ac.uk
John G. Ewen;
Institute of Zoology, ZSL, UK; john.ewen@ioz.ac.uk
Stefano Canessa;
ARC Centre of Excellence for Environmental Decisions, School of Botany,
University of Melbourne, Australia; canessas@unimelb.edu.au
A recurrent
problem stated in reintroduction biology is the lack of a clear definition of
reintroduction success. The rapidly growing literature on reintroductions
highlights the wide diversity of definitions used (we will include a short
review). Although reconciling such diversity into a single overarching metric
can appear desirable, success criteria for any given reintroduction program
should be chosen primarily to reflect its specific objectives. In turn,
objectives should be carefully defined to correspond to the aspirations and
preferences that motivate the reintroduction effort. Indeed, most reintroduction
programs will aim to achieve multiple ecological, social and economic
objectives. In this chapter, we identify the objectives most commonly shared by
reintroduction programs, and describe how they can be developed into some more
commonly shared metrics of success within a systematic and transparent
decision-making process. We argue that, to optimise the choice of success
criteria, reintroduction practitioners should frame reintroductions as decision
problems and use formal approaches of decision theory to guide the entire
reintroduction process.
Structured
Decision Making (SDM) is such a framework, allowing managers to identify the
action strategy that is expected to provide the best possible outcome in
relation to value-based objectives, accounting for uncertainty and
multi-objective trade-offs. SDM is increasingly being used for planning and
implementing species reintroductions (we will include a short review). We give
a brief overview of SDM and the step process involved, and highlight why it is
the best practice for planning translocations (include case study as box text
TBC). Since it places particular importance on value-based decisions, SDM is
especially suited for identifying objectives and criteria of success for
complex decisions. Therefore, we use this framework to discuss the potential
objectives for reintroductions against which success can be determined. We will
present a range of possible concerns commonly faced in reintroduction planning
and implementation. For each point discussed, we focus on the pros and cons of
using these concerns as objectives for a reintroduction. Where potential
objectives are conflicting we will show how to approach trade-offs and
prioritisation, accounting for the possibility that different objectives are
not equally valued (potentially include a box text example TBC). We will also
describe how to treat cases where measurable attributes of given objectives are
difficult to quantify.
Finally, we
conclude this chapter with recommendations for future research and application
of decision theory in reintroduction. We discuss how incorporating methods from
economics and social sciences could increase the ability of managers to deal
with multiple objectives in reintroductions. We will also discuss how this more
structured approach to reintroductions allows or reduces the ability for broad
scale meta-analyses of reintroduction studies, an approach that may place
demands on standardised metrics of success.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 6: Genetic issues in animal reintroduction
Iris Biebach, Debbie Leigh, Kasia Sluzek and Lukas F. Keller from the University of Zürich
By their very nature, reintroductions are also experiments in genetics. Inbreeding, genetic drift, and adaptation are genetic processes that all take place during the typical phases of a reintroduction project. They, therefore, can play an important role in determining the long-term success of reintroductions. The aims of this chapter are to describe the genetic issues that occur during reintroductions and to highlight key points in the decision making process where genetic considerations should be included. Finally, we will also provide guidelines for practitioners how to maximize genetic potential in reintroduced populations.
The first part of the chapter deals in detail with genetic drift and inbreeding. Genetic drift, inbreeding and the causes of inbreeding depression are explained, and the consequences of inbreeding depression will be discussed at the individual and the population level. We will also discuss the role of purging in reducing inbreeding depression, and compare the effects of purging to the risk of fixation. We also address the long-term consequences of lost genetic diversity, a reduction in adaptive potential. Throughout, we will discuss the relevance for reintroduction biology, the theoretical background and the methods required to estimate some of the quantities in reintroduction projects.
In the second part of the chapter, we will address the genetic aspects of three steps that often come up in planning and conducting a reintroduction. First, when only few individuals survive in the wild, captive breeding is sometimes necessary to enhance the number of individuals available for release. We consider genetic issues associated with captive breeding such as how to minimize loss of genetic diversity and adaptation to captivity. Second, selecting the number and origin of founder individuals is another key issue in reintroductions that have long-lasting genetic effects on the reintroduced populations. Analysis of reintroduced populations with known founder history allows insights into how to choose a founder group to reduce inbreeding and maintain high genetic diversity in a reintroduced population. Problems of outbreeding depression are also discussed that might arise if genetically very divergent individuals are combined in a founder group. Finally, we address the question how reintroduced populations can be monitored once they are established to detect genetic problems, and we discuss possible management options after the first release phase.
We exemplify some of the genetic issues in reintroductions with a case study of Alpine ibex. Studies on reintroduced Alpine ibex populations are used to illustrate (1) how to measure genetic drift and inbreeding using genetic markers, (2) how founder group size, founder composition, and population growth affects inbreeding and genetic variation, (3) how to select individuals to reduce inbreeding in an established population, and (4) inbreeding depression on population growth rate. A second case study of reintroduced Takahe in New Zealand will also be discussed in detail.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 7: Accounting for potential physiological and behavioral responses to reintroduction
David Jachowski, Virginia Tech
Samantha Bremner-Harrison, Nottingham Trent University
David Steen, Auburn University
Kim Aarestrup, Technical University of Denmark
The responses of fish and wildlife to reintroduction can often dictate the success or failure of a reintroduction attempt. Responses can be subtle or dramatic, often requiring monitoring at a variety of scales ranging from individual physiology, to population or even community-level behavioral responses. In an effort to help reintroduction practitioners better consider and account for potential responses that could influence reintroduction success, in this chapter we will review the physiological and behavioral responses that have been observed in fish and wildlife populations following reintroduction. We will first review physiological responses common to reintroduced populations such as altered concentrations of testosterone and stress hormones, and adjusted parturition in females. Second, we will review common individual behavioral responses. Across taxa, the most common behavioral response of management concern following reintroductions is dispersal away from the release site. Conversely, in some species, enhancing dispersal and even training reintroduced populations to migrate is needed. Third, within populations, behavioral responses vary among individuals, indicative of individual personality. We will review how variation in boldness among individuals can have important effects on observed behavioral responses to reintroduction. Fourth, interactions among released individuals are critically important in many species, and accounting for social behavior and territorial aggression must be considered. Finally, we will discuss inter-specific behavioral interactions that should be considered prior to reintroduction. This will include discussion of the impact of predation (by both resident predators and novel predators in the case of some introduced species) on reintroduced populations, as well as the potential for cascading trophic interactions to occur post-release in some instances. To illustrate these major themes we will make extensive use of case studies, and include a box inset profiling extensive work done on African elephants that highlights the need to consider many of the above mentioned potential physiological and behavioral issues. We will conclude the chapter with a summary of considerations that reintroduction practitioners should consider for mitigating and monitoring these issues, as well as priorities for further research on the topic.
Chapter 8: Why you can’t ignore disease when you are translocating animals
Erin Muths1 and Hamish McCallum2
1U.S. Geological Survey, Fort Collins Science Center, Colorado, USA
2Griffith University, Queensland, Australia
Infectious disease is an important consideration when contemplating reintroduction of a species to an area from which it has been extirpated and is one risk that has escalated in recent decades as use of large-scale and hands-on conservation measures increase. Reintroduction (in essence moving animals around), is a management tool considered when populations are failing or extirpations have occurred, yet is obviously at odds with many of the tenets of disease management. We focus on extirpations attributed to disease and formulate a decision tree to guide managers considering reintroduction. If disease was not the original cause of extinction, it still is important to consider as inadvertent introduction of disease with reintroduced hosts may cause a reintroduction to fail, or may threaten members of the recipient ecological community. If disease was an important agent of extinction, then the disease threat must be addressed before reintroduction is contemplated, or the effort is highly likely to fail. If disease resistant or tolerant stock are available, then reintroducing these animals may succeed. If such stock are not available, then it is important to determine whether reservoirs are present, and if they are, to develop strategies to manage disease adequately in the reservoirs. If reservoirs are not present, then the biggest threat to a reintroduction is the presence of still-infected members of the species being reintroduced. We illustrate these principles with two case studies, the boreal toad, threatened by the amphibian chytrid fungus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis and the Tasmanian devil, threatened by a transmissible cancer.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 8: Why You Can’t Ignore Disease When You Translocate AnimalsAuthors: Erin Muths and Hamish McCallum
Infectious disease is an important
consideration when contemplating reintroduction of a species to an area from
which it has been extirpated and is one risk that has escalated in recent
decades as use of large-scale and hands-on conservation measures increase.
Reintroduction (in essence moving animals around), is a management tool
considered when populations are failing or extirpations have occurred, yet is
obviously at odds with many of the tenets of disease management. We focus on
extirpations attributed to disease and formulate a decision tree to guide
managers considering reintroduction. If disease was not the original cause of
extinction, it still is important to consider as inadvertent introduction of
disease with reintroduced hosts may cause a reintroduction to fail, or may
threaten members of the recipient ecological community. If disease was an
important agent of extinction, then the disease threat must be addressed before
reintroduction is contemplated, or the effort is highly likely to fail. If
disease resistant or tolerant stock are
available, then reintroducing these animals may succeed. If such stock are not
available, then it is important to determine whether reservoirs are present,
and if they are, to develop strategies to manage disease adequately in the
reservoirs. If reservoirs are not present, then the biggest threat to a
reintroduction is the presence of still-infected members of the species being
reintroduced. We illustrate these principles with two case studies, the boreal
toad, threatened by the amphibian chytrid fungus Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis and the Tasmanian devil, threatened
by a transmissible cancer.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 9: Release Strategies
Axel Moehrenschlager, Calgary Zoo/University of Calgary
Others to be determined…
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter 10: Designing Monitoring to Evaluate and Improve Reintroduction Success
Robert A. Gitzen (School of Forestry and Wildlife Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL USA) and Joshua J. Millspaugh (Department of Fisheries and Wildlife Sciences, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO USA)
In this chapter, we use lessons from case studies of a variety of species along with general principles of conservation monitoring to demonstrate how to carefully develop a reintroduction monitoring program. A reintroduction effort should have clearly defined definitions for success in the short, medium, and long-term. The initial reintroduction should carefully consider factors hypothesized to be most important in determining reintroduction success, and what subsequent decisions may arise (e.g. whether and how to release more animals) as initial results are evaluated. These management objectives, hypotheses, and potential future decisions provide the framework for conducting monitoring, both in terms of what to measure and how accurately to measure it. Frequently, monitoring initially will focus heavily on individual survival, movements from the release site, health (e.g. stress, disease), recruitment, and interactions with humans. With increasing time, management definitions for success, and therefore conservation monitoring, may focus more on population growth rate and expansion, genetic status, and effects on other resources. However, at all time scales, choices about whether and what to monitor should be based on the goal of reducing important sources of uncertainty affecting future decisions facing the reintroduction program. How much this uncertainty needs to be reduced to improve subsequent reintroduction decisions dictates the quality of information, which is determined by the statistical design of the program in relation to importance sources of variability and potential bias. Decisions about monitoring are part of the suite of management decisions facing a reintroduction program, all of which may be evaluated in a structured approach focused on optimizing probability of a successful reintroduction. This ensures that monitoring is treated as an integrated component of an overall reintroduction program rather than an amorphous exercise in data collection.
Chapter 11: Demographic considerations in reintroduction planning
Authors: Sarah J Conversea and Doug P Armstrong b
aUSGS Patuxent Wildlife Research Center, 12100 Beech Forest Road, Laurel MD 20708; sconverse@usgs.gov
bWildlife Ecology Group, Massey University, PB 11222, Palmerston North,
New Zealand; D.P.Armstrong@massey.ac.nz
A primary objective of reintroductions is typically the
establishment of a self-sustaining population with a high probability of
persistence. Given this, demography must be a major focus of planning and
evaluating reintroduction efforts. To improve the chances of reintroduction
success, demographic issues should be considered during pre-release planning
and throughout the process of managing the reintroduction effort. We suggest that
decision analysis, and especially adaptive management, provides the proper
frame for considering demographic issues. Adaptive management is a special case
of decision analysis in which decisions are iterated over time, where
uncertainty impedes the identification of the optimal action, and where
monitoring can be used to reduce uncertainty and improve decision-making
through time.
The first step in planning a reintroduction is setting the
objectives – the basic values of the managers in the context of the
reintroduction. Typically, fundamental objectives will involve long-term
persistence of the reintroduced population. Second, the set of possible action
alternatives must be identified – these may include options such as different
release sites, release methods, or sex/age structures in the release cohort.
Finally, model(s) must be developed to make predictions about how different
actions will influence the demographic objectives.
The construction of demographic decision models facilitates
the prediction of the effects of actions on population metrics. These models
will be of varying complexity depending on the needs of the decision-makers,
and the available data and modeling resources. While conceptual models may be a
starting point, quantitative models will be most useful for guiding decisions
and integrating monitoring data. We recognize 5 steps in building demographic
models: structuring and planning the model(s), construction of initial
model(s), demographic estimation using available data, identification of
information gaps to be filled via expert judgment, and, finally, use of the
model(s) for evaluating the effects of action alternatives. Major sources of
uncertainty should be included, which will allow for the identification of
action alternatives that are optimal given both what is known and, importantly,
what is unknown.
Demographic models for reintroduction management need to be
designed to accommodate the unique characteristics of reintroduced populations.
Particular concerns include post-release effects, Allee effects, demographic
stochasticity, and transitory dynamics caused by the initial age and sex composition
of the released cohort. In addition, there will often be the need to build
models relating to the source population – whether wild or captive – to
identify sustainable removals. In the case of captive sources, models will often
include both demographic and genetic considerations in tandem, as captive
population managers typically value the conservation of genetic diversity.
In this chapter, we will lay out the process of planning for
reintroductions and managing reintroduced populations using demographic models.
We will present a general decision-theoretic framework, specifically with
respect to demographic objectives. We will then present detailed
recommendations on how to build demographic models that can be used within such
a framework. Throughout, aspects of the process will be illustrated with 2
major case studies: reintroductions of whooping cranes (Grus americana) and hihi (Notiomystis cincta).
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter
12: Management of reintroduced populations
Matt Hayward and Rob Slotow
When we consider
wildlife reintroduction programmes, we normally speak of these as reintroduced
populations, highlighting the importance of success in terms of population.
While we may think of success in terms of population viability, or of
population sustainability with no further intervention, the reality is much
less definitive. In this chapter we
clarify what have been used as indicators of success in terms of populations of
reintroduced species, and evaluate measurements of success against these
indicators. We provide a context of biological understanding, especially from a
systems perspective, in how we need to scrutinize populations of reintroduced
species, including consideration of metapopulation approaches. We then
investigate how scientists and managers have intervened to promote success in
these measures, through habitat manipulation, including fire management
supplemental feeding, water provisioning and fencing, manipulating the
community assemblage, including their predators or prey, population
supplementation, and finally population control when we have become too
successful. Based on this foundation, we evaluate how well we have done so far
with reintroduced populations, and reflect on how we have approached this, and
where we have been successful or failed. We present broad analyses across taxa
using the primary literature and the IUCN Global Reintroduction perspectives
(Soorae 2008, 2010, 2011, 2012), and explore the issues in depth through case
studies of three species, African Elephant, African Wild dog (maybe choose
something else such as a bird), and XXXXX.
Specifically, we ask two questions, how well we have learned from the
experience of many reintroductions across a wide range of taxa, and how well
has the learned experience been shared, i.e. does experience convert to
learning with sharing, and is this then translated into evidence-based best
practice. Finally, we ask the question, once we have acted as God to
reintroduce a species, do we feel compelled to continue to act as God to manage
that species, or could we do well enough to leave them to their own devices.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter
13: Outreach
and Environmental Education for Reintroduction Programs
Anna George, Tennessee Aquarium, alg@tnaqua.org
Estelle Sandhaus, Santa Barbara Zoo,
ESandhaus@sbzoo.org
Dante Fenolio, San Antonio Zoo, Dante@anotheca.com
Abstract
Much like publishing remains a key output for
scientific research, outreach and environmental education are key outputs in
reintroduction programs. Outreach is a critical step in the success of
reintroduction programs, as it can be used to influence behavior in the general
public, such as altering attitudes towards hunting the reintroduced animal,
such as gray wolves, or encouraging resource users to report sightings of the
animal, such as for imperiled game fishes. The reintroduced animal can also be
used a flagship species to raise more concern in the general public about a
critical habitat that is threatened by human actions. Both funders and
policymakers deserve special attention in order to promote long-term support
for the reintroduction effort. More specialized audiences that may merit
outreach include private breeders, particularly for amphibians and reptiles
where individuals can be sold through the private trade to raise money for in situ conservation efforts, or citizen
scientists, who may help monitor the reintroduced animal. Thus, the perception
that environmental education is most effectively targeted at children needs to
be broadened for reintroduction programs. Reintroduction outreach should be
flexible and diverse, targeting all stakeholders for a reintroduction program,
from schoolchildren to funders to policymakers to resource users to citizen
scientists.
Before beginning outreach, program leaders should
understand current attitudes and knowledge towards the animal and habitat.
Ideally, this is undertaken prior to implementation of reintroduction for
planning purposes. If not, the resulting data will help guide which outreach
programs need to be undertaken with what audiences using which key messages. In
addition, these attitude surveys can be used during and after the
reintroduction to assess whether outreach is working and what needs to be
changed. Outreach programs can take a variety of forms depending on key
audiences and messages. Because zoos and aquariums were early pioneers in
captive husbandry techniques to maintain collections, and because of their
large annual audiences, one of the most traditional forms of reintroduction
outreach is exhibits or displays in zoos, aquariums, and museums (ZAMs) that
feature the reintroduction animal. The animal is often presented as an
ambassador for the habitat, and conservation behaviors for the general public
may be taught by these displays. These educational displays have expanded in
recent years with some ZAM programs using classrooms as alternate locations for
raising animals for reintroduction. In other instances, schoolchildren and the
general public have been invited to help release animals, providing education
not only to those in attendance, but the broader public through the media
stories that follow. More targeted stories aimed at various resource groups are
possible, using specialized forms of traditional media (specialty magazines,
fishing guides) or internet media (social media, hunting/fishing forums).
Less-used forms of outreach take the form of compensation payments to
landowners based on loss or damage due to reintroduction efforts. Ideally,
these efforts all combine to provide broad and targeted support for the
reintroduction program over the long-term.
Outline
- Why
- Protection
of released animals (influence behavior)
- Awareness
of problem—flagship species
- Monitoring
help
- Long-term
fundraising and support
- Who
- Policymakers/Politicians
- K-12
students
- Resource
users
- Landowners
- Media
- Citizen Scientists
- Private
Breeders
i.
Particular concern for amphibian, snake
programs (Browne et al. 2011)
- Fellow
scientists
i.
Universities key to success of projects
based on science expertise (Lawson et al. 2008, Browne et al. 2011)
- Resource
managers
i.
Government agencies (e.g., USFWS,
National Park Service)
ii.
NGOs such as Peregrine Fund
- Funders
i.
Corporate partners (e.g.,
AZA-Microsoft’s “Zoo Tycoon” collaboration)
ii.
Foundations
- How: What,
When, Where
- Measureable
- Attitude
Surveys
- Exhibits
and displays (ZAMs)
i.
Maintain species in captivity for
education (zoo sustainability issues, e.g. Griffiths and Pavajeau 2008)
- Classroom
programs
i.
Adopt-a-Trout program with K-12
curricula to track trout following release (Schmetterling and Bernd-Cohen 2002)
ii.
Raise animals in classroom
1. Shad
in the Classroom (NC)
2. Lake
Sturgeon (TN)
- Public
releases/parties
i.
Adopt/name a fish (Adopt-a-Herring, MA;
Frank et al. 2009)
ii.
Condor releases (e.g., Peregrine Fund,
National Park Service, Ventana Wildlife Society)
- Media
Stories
i.
Luna the Lamprey (USFWS)
- Targeted
Publications
i.
Fishing guides (TWRA)
ii.
Nonlead information for hunters (e.g.,
video spot on Arizona Dept of Game and Fish DVD sent to those who received
rifle deer tags via lottery, brochures for hunters that are distributed by
National Park Service)
- Compensation
for property loss
- Questions
to expect
Key examples:
- Lake
sturgeon
- Black-footed
ferret
- Wolves—Yellowstone
- Whooping
Crane
- Condors
- Frogs
- Possibly add a reptile and/or invertebrate?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapter
14: Past,
present and future of fish and wildlife restoration
Authors:
David Jachowski, Joshua Millspaugh, Paul Angermeier, Rob Slotow
In this chapter we will first synthesize material
from the preceding chapters and the primary literature to provide an overview
of key lessons learned from past attempts to reintroduce species. We will provide an overview of how the pieces
of the reintroduction process fit together in terms of conceptualization for
planning a reintroduction, permitting, implementation, monitoring, further management,
evaluation and reflection. We will
illustrate how utilizing this framework, and what links are missing from the
“chain”, can highlight current priorities in research and other programmatic
areas that will enhance our ability to successfully enhance species
reintroduction. We will then relate this
framework to existing regulatory frameworks and IUCN reintroduction
guidelines. The second major component
of this chapter will be focused on the long-term future of fish and wildlife
restoration. This will involve
discussing topics that are currently or likely to soon be debated such as
community-based (rather than single species-based) approaches to
restoration. We will also discuss
extensions of reintroduction biology practices to topics such as managed
introduction and assisted colonization.
Because such actions require a slight relaxation of baselines inherent
in “reintroduction” (i.e., not within the historic range of the species so not
technically a reintroduction), we will touch on broader philosophical issues
that are likely to emerge – particularly increased attention focused on
embracing novel ecosystems, urban conservation, and ecosystem engineering. Finally, we will conclude with a big picture
review of how reintroduction biology fits within the larger practice of
conservation biology, how it benefits conservation as a whole, and how it can
be applied in increasingly controversial arenas such as the emergent
de-extinction debate.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment